Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?

deviantART

:woohoo:
 

Contest Results + Rant

Sun Feb 22, 2009, 9:10 PM
Here are the result for the contest. Now, due to the lack of sufficient entries, I've decided to remove the "Quality" categories. It's not that the entries weren't of quality, but since there weren't enough of them, it was a bit unfair to judge them when most of the good one already went into the other categories.

So the results go as follow:

******************************
For the Favorite Category:
******************************

First place goes to Comus for his dolphin transformation. Nice work, funny image. Made me smile. The context he used was Flipper, both a movie and a TF series.
* [link]

Second place goes to Metamorpher for the crocodile transformation. Nice pace, nice pose. Nice tail. The context he used was Peter Pan, in reference to the crocodile and the ticking watch.
* [link]
* [link]
* [link]

Third place goes to Inuebony for the Ninja Tribunal Dragon transformation. I haven't seen that arc yet, but the dragons looked quite nice. The context he used was the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 20003 TF series.
* [link]
* [link]
* [link]
* [link]

Fourth place goes to HyperJet for the shark TF. He used Jaws as the context.
* [link]

Fifth place goes to Ageaus for his Viashino transformation. Viashino is a species from the card game Magic the Gathering.
* [link]

******************************
For the Originality Category:
******************************

First place goes to SesakaHeart for the Thing TF. I nearly felt off my chair when I saw it. It was totally unexpected. The thing is an horror movie, which she used as reference.
* [link]

Second place goes to Lukery for the pig transformation. He had found a good way to mix the site, show and contest. He used the movie Willow as the context.
* [link]
* [link]
* [link]

Third place goes to KitsuneKit for the rat transformation. He used a classic in the Transformation community: Disney's Aladdin, the Series.
* [link]

Fourth place goes to Avancna for the dragon TF. He used Disney's Sleeping Beauty well known dragon Transformation as the context.
* [link]
* [link]

******************************
For stories and other media:
******************************

First place goes to Ageaus for his Simic Induction stories, based upon the Magic: the Gathering universe.
* [link]

Second place goes to Comus, for his Dolphin transformation stories telling the stories of his picture who won the first prize in favorite.
* [link]

Third and fourth places goes to Morwalugi for his 2 dragon transformations written and narrated stories.
* [link]
* [link]


Congratulation to the winner. I'll be contacting you regarding your prize.
Thanks for participating.

******************************
Rant ahead
******************************

Now, about this contest.

Personally, I'm very disappointed with how it turned out. The first one went very smoothly: good feedback, plenty of entries and support for the work I was doing for the site.
This time, now that the site was finally up, I get about no positive entries about it. What was it all about? Now that the site is up and running, no need to support the one that do the job? Or is it something? Let me know, I want to know what went wrong.

I asked a friend what was his thought about it. He told me that people talked to him about my contest. The lack of entries and support then wasn't related to not broadcasting enough the contest. What he told me was that the contest was 'too much like the previous one'.

Too much like the previous one? Come on. It's a transformation website, it has to be TF related. The other factor was I was the transformed, me or my character. Now, please someone explains to me how come, in Deviantart, all the recurring "draw my character" contests pass as original, but because it's me who do one of those, it's different?
So what, those contest just change the context between contest. Draw my character doing ninja stuff. Draw my character as a kanji. I'm supposed to be unoriginal? Please, explain where I was wrong.

Second, I was told the rules were complicated. Well, why has nobody told me? Why has anybody asked me question about it? AFTER the contest, someone came to me with that question. He told me orca, told him 4 example of TF, all featuring either an orca or a show. Street shark evil scientific changing me into an orca. Being turned into an orca to perform in a show (willy), etc.

Third, how come people are willing to bust their ass doing free and "stupid" (that was the opinion of 2 artists who brought that up) "transformation challenge" like zodiac, cursed candy, girl TF for another website than only leeched artists for years and never gave back for their work. I though giving money as prize would interest people, but I guess the whole "starving artists" is a myth if they prefer to do free challenge.

Fourth, thanks you very much, sarcastically speaking, to everyone that told me they were very interested join the contest, and toss it aside completely. I imagine what are their thought now: "Hehe, sucker!".

No seriously, if I got it work, feel free to correct me.

I dunno if I'll run another contest. I was running this one as a welcome back for myself, after nearly 3 years away to bring some life back to the community. But I guess the community is in zombie mode: more interested in eating brain that being constructive. Thanks for the 'un' support really.

The week before the contest end, I was nearly doing an update every morning, uploading 5-10 shows a day. Well, guess what, it won't happens again. From now on, there will be only one update a week, on Saturday. If, for some personal reason such as being on week-end duty like this week-end, I cannot update, then the update will be delayed to either sunday if I feel like it, or next Saturday.

I mean, donation have stopped, people do not support the arts gallery nor do give feedback what they would want in it to make it work and people weren't supportive with the contest. Why should I stress over an update then, if it's to snorted at or spammed on IM (see [link] ).

So, this being vented, thank for those who participated. I'll be emailing/Instant messaging you sometime this week.

Feel free to offer your opinion on what went wrong, what do I need t change, what I got wrong, etc, because seriously, I don't get what everyone else want.

  • Mood: Anxious
  • Drinking: Water

Devious Comments

love 1 1 joy 1 1 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 1 1
:iconinuebony:
Woot that was fun and seeing the other entries was even more joyful of the experience

--
"Blood is good says the Drunken Vampyre ^vv^"
:iconlizardman76:
Unfortunately, the donations aren't going to happen too often right now. The market in the US is going down still, and it's almost time to file for taxes. More companies are laying off... people just aren't sure of the future.

I don't know what else to tell you. Things are just bad all over for so many people. Perhaps even a short hiatus, or just fewer hours put into the site for a few months, will help out a bit. People who love the site will realize that it's not as effective without you plugging away like you have been and see how they can help out? Or perhaps that's just being too optimistic.
:iconrummelhart:
Putting up hand tentatively: What exactly did people GET for entering? I searched through this journal entry and I guess it's just me, but I couldn't find anything people got for entering this contest.

--
My brain in a jar: [link]

My life in a saucepan: [link]
:iconmetamorpher:
Yay ^vvv^ I got second. I laughed when you said "Nice pace, nice pose. Nice tail" on my entry XD.


As for why people didn' do it. Sorry I am not really sure. In a way, I also didn't really want to enter as well. Not sure why. But I did ^^

--
Well, everyone needs a little change. Even if it is to another species.
:icontrumangrace:
For the donation thing, in an economic downturn, donations are usually the first thing to go. It's not just you, every group that relies on donations see trouble in economic downturns. The only ones who won't be as affected are students, and they don't seem to be heavy donors anyways. When you aren't sure if you're going to have a job the next year, you're not going to spend as much, and when you do it tends to be more for actual goods or services and less for donations.

Of course, that doesn't explain lack of feedback or interest in a contest, but it may go hand in hand more than we think.
:iconhyperjet:
YEAH #4!

I was/am interested in the art gallery but didn't know how to subscribe. You have a very good and comprehensive site. I'm new to all this but my advice to you is to keep trekking on. Things go in cycles.
:iconwerewolf2993:
The whole economy around the world is going down, that's definitely a factor.

Those entries were really good though. ^_^

--
Life is but a box of chocolates, you never know which one you'll get.
:icondragoniade:
That's the best thing about contest or throw idea: You get to see other's interpretation of a same subject.

--
Visit my transformation website: [link]
:icondragoniade:
The prizes, along with the contest description, were listed in the original announcement and a link to that announcement on every update, along with my signature.

They were pointing to those 3 links.
[link]
[link]
[link]

And to get to the point, there originally was 4 categories (originality, skills, favorite and stories/other media) , each category had 5 prizes, which were, in order, 35$ + 4 DVD rom of TF clips taken from the site, 20$ + 3 DVD rom, 10$ + 2 DVD rom, 2 DVD rom and lastly, 1 DVD rom

--
Visit my transformation website: [link]

Site Map